What is the difference between -hivevar and -hiveconf?

Question

From hive -h :

--hiveconf <property=value>   Use value for given property
--hivevar <key=value>         Variable subsitution to apply to hive
                                  commands. e.g. --hivevar A=B

Answer 1

I didn't quite feel like the examples from the documentation were adequate, so here's my attempt at an answer.

In the beginning there was only --hiveconf and variable substitution didn't exist.

The --hiveconf option allowed users to set Hive configuration values from the command line and that was it. All Hive configuration values are stored under the hiveconf namespace, i.e. hiveconf:mapred.reduce.tasks. These values allowed you to control things like the number of mappers and reducers, if status messages should be displayed, and if the script should continue on errors.

Later, variable substitution was added. This meant you could now use variables in queries with the ${...} syntax. However, the only variables you could set from the command line were under the hiveconf namespace using --hiveconf, so that's where users put their variables.

Putting your personal variables under the Hive configuration namespace probably won't break anything, but it's also not good form. Later, it was suggested that a hivevar namespace be added specifically for user variables which could also be defined at the command line using --hivevar. This meant a cleaner separation between Hive configuration values and user defined variables.

In summary:
The hiveconf namespace and --hiveconf should be used to set Hive configuration values.
The hivevar namespace and --hivevar should be used to define user variables.
Setting user variables under the hiveconf namespace probably won't break anything, but isn't recommended.

Answer 2

@Llama has explained it in detailed, along with that both type of variables are accessed differently.

The --hivevar variables are accessed using ${var-name}, while the --hiveconf are accessed ${hiveconf:var-name} inside hive.

e.g. Below examples access variable and print it's value in hive.

hivevar:

hive --hivevar a='this is a' -e '!echo ${a};'

output:this is a

hiveconf:

hive --hiveconf a='this is a' -e '!echo ${hiveconf:a};'

output:this is a

Answer 3

We can also use them at the beginning of the script as:

hiveconf:

SET this_dt = CURRENT_DATE;
select ${hiveconf:this_dt};

hivevar:

set hivevar:cur_dt=current_date;
select ${hivevar:cur_dt};

Answer 4

You can refer this for the difference

https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/Hive/LanguageManual+VariableSubstitution

There are three namespaces for variables – hiveconf, system, and env. (Custom variables can also be created in a separate namespace with the define or hivevar option in Hive 0.8.0 and later releases.)

Answer 5

No difference except the namespace. hiveconf and hivevar are different namespaces. hivevar namespace was added just to separate configuration properties namespace and Hive variables namespace. See https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HIVE-2020 for more information.